Details

Publisher

Commons Press

Edition

1st

Year of publication

2023

Number of pages

81

Language

English

Paperback ISBN

978-1-7374810-5-8

Hardcover ISBN

978-1-7374810-2-7

The Malthus Fraud

by Robert Dees • 5 reviews


The defeat of the British government by American revolutionaries and the role of the laboring classes in overthrowing the French monarchy in the late 1700s inspired confidence among working people and fear among the elites, posing the need for an ideological counterattack. The Essay on Population was Malthus’s contribution to this battle of ideas.

He argued that society’s ills are caused not by the greed-driven capitalist system, but by working people “overpopulating.” The fact that there is not a single historical ex­ample that supports his doctrine has had no effect on its continuing popularity among today’s propagandists for the status quo. This is be­cause it never was a scientific theory, but a religious-political dogma, more akin to antisemitism and racism. It serves to divert us from carrying out the necessary revolutionary solutions to the problems we face.

This booklet is an excerpt from The Power of Peasants: Economics and Politics of Farming in Medieval Germany.

available in

Kindle

$6.00

Also available in Europe on:
🇬🇧 Amazon UK (£4.49) | 🇩🇪 Amazon DE (€5.50)

Paperback

$15.00

Also available in Europe on:
🇬🇧 Amazon UK (£13.00) | 🇩🇪 Amazon DE (€14.00)


Reviews (5)


FEATURED REVIEW

“With power and clarity, Dees dismantles Malthus’s claims…. The Malthus Fraud is well- documented, sharply argued, and never dry despite its scholarly heft…. Brisk, blistering critique of Malthus and Malthusian ideology.”

Michael Roberts

Review of Agrarian Studies

“Dees does a demolition job on the population theory of the reactionary nineteenth century English parson, Thomas Malthus.“

Dominic Alexander

Counterfire Books of the Year 2025

“Brilliantly succeeds in demolishing Malthusian explanations for the miseries of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries.”

D. Donovan

Midwest Book Review

“Robert Dees provides a damning, eye-opening argument in The Malthus Fraud, which should engage and challenge history students already well versed in Malthus’s traditional thinking…. Through this analysis, the roots of dogma and misguided interpretations and perspectives are revealed in a manner that offers many insights for classrooms interested in not just historical analysis and Malthus, but the underlying belief systems that dictate its process…. The result is of critical importance to historians, scholars, and student debate groups who already hold familiarity with Malthus and the long-term impact of his approach. Libraries and readers seeking books that explore the foundations of religious and political dogma to consider their lasting influence on social issues and historical approaches will find The Malthus Fraud thought- provoking, astute, and certainly controversial in its contentions – perfect fodder for classroom and history buff discussion groups.”

Kirkus Reviews

“Dees reveals the underlying prejudices and misconceptions that Malthusian theory propagates. The author writes with directness and no shortage of attitude; the reader gets a healthy sense of Dees’ distaste for his subject and can’t help but partake in it…. Even those who don’t consider themselves Malthusian scholars will likely find much of Dees’ evidence to be revelatory, especially when it comes to the notion of overpopulation. Those worried about the coming demographic apocalypse can rest easier. A slim but persuasive consideration of the popularity and wrongheadedness of Malthusian population theory.”


Related books

Browse all books→

The Power of Peasants

Advances in agricultural production by farmers played the decisive role in the great advances in civilization in Europe. Looking at history from the perspective of the farmers and other working people allows us to understand why history took the course it did and better prepare us for battles that lie ahead.


VIEW BOOK PAGE →

A Brief History of England

A factual but humorously written romp through English history, highlighting the role of farmers in driving many of its key turning points, including winning the Forest Charter and Magna Carta. This victory was key to farmers winning their freedom from serfdom and from there, producing the agricultural surpluses that powered England’s rise to world domination.


VIEW BOOK PAGE →